Show me a band that thinks it's 'all about the music,' and I'll show you a band with 14 listens on Spotify. It's just never that simple; the notes and lyrics rarely exist in isolation.
No, it isn't. It's a saying that needs to be deleted; a purist attitude that will kill a career. Because the most successful artists frequently go way beyond the music, in fact, they sometimes gain success in spite of their crappy and forgettable songs. This is about a package that includes looks, a connection to a scene, location, religion, or subculture, not to mention a certain celebrity factor. Guns n' Roses wrote some of the greatest music of all time, but they also excited dirty sexuality, self-abusive indulgence, and everything your parents fucking hated. They lived this life, it was dangerous.
Other, more modern examples aren't hard to find. Adele lacks the supermodel look but that's the point: she has emotional resonance, she has deeply-emotional music and a connection with all the inadequate-feeling non-supermodels. John Mayer has looks, the celebrity factor, and songs that excite female fantasies better than a Hollywood chick-flick. What we're talking about is packages that contain an important musical component, not music in isolation. Even purist genres like classical and jazz go way beyond the virtuosities.

It's not just fans, it's everyone that has any emotional connection to a group. If you hate Insane Clown Posse, the Juggalos, and everything that goes with that scene, then you're bolstering the cause and the band. Because Juggalo superfans are not only defined by their subcultural attitudes, but also the adverse reaction they get from mainstream society and authorities. Indeed, the Juggalos have been now classified as a 'loosely organized hybrid gang' by the FBI, up there with the Bloods, Crips, and Aryan Brotherhood.
There's a sullied and complicated story here. But from the standpoint of building a cult-like following, you couldn't ask for anything better. Because the world has now granted the Juggalos the highest form of 'otherness' and outcast (albeit voluntary) identity possible. Which brings us to last Friday, when ICP emcees Violent J and Shaggy 2 Dope opened a legal defense fund to help Juggalos that are facing discrimination because of alleged gang affiliations. Everyone's in this together, they're going to fight the man, the Feds, and the overbearing US Government.
'Us against them' has never been so perfectly captured in a bottle. It's dangerous, scary to authorities, attacked, and intensely bonding to members. It's not mainstream, it may never be, and that's also the point.
This isn't the first time that a band has created an entire scene or even subculture. But it seems that the 'everything else' is so frequently missed by discovery apps and tech-driven musical ideas. Because algorithms don't create stars, at best, they can spark something bigger. This is about inspiring the rawest of emotions, the most deep-rooted anger, longings for the most misguided love affairs and fixations we can't shake loose. Not to mention psychological needs for association, identity, and definition from other groups. It's what good music marketing and real fan bonding is all about, and what 'discovery' and technology usually isn't.
/paul. Written while listening to ICP, Beethoven's 4th, and Appetite for Destruction.

David Monday, August 13, 2012
I don't know anything about the Juggalos, but in the aftermath of the Sikh Temple killings, classifying some genres of music as worthy of police scrutiny does not seem such a terrible idea.

JJ Monday, August 13, 2012
Slippery slope my friend.
You know Hatebreed got caught up in all of that? Guess the feds thought they were a hate or skinhead band, they're not at all.

Tone Monday, August 13, 2012
Authoritianism? No thanks.

David Monday, August 13, 2012
Authoritianism? No dictionary.
I'm not suggesting that Nazi hate 'artists' should be banned (though in many countries they are), but it is legitimate for law enforcement agencies to scrutinise whatever evidence is available of people's criminal intentions.

Central Scrutinizer Tuesday, August 14, 2012
Your attitude is music to my ears and every politician on the planet.
It is important to remember that politicians use law enforcement as a tool to gain power and maintian it.
Also, the definition of what is criminal changes depending on which way the political wind is blowing.
Maybe the activities and communications of every commenter on DMN should be monitored.
A clever politician could convince anough voters that everyone who is involved in the music business is a potential Kim Dotcom and therefore should be monitored for copyright infringement, tax evasion and money laundering.
I am looking forward to your vote in the next election, if not we'll be watching you.

chicagojuggalo Monday, August 27, 2012
It's not about the music, it's the fact that some icp fans look/act/talk like or want to be gang members.
I find it really ignorant to label "Juggalo's" as a gang, the aryan brotherhood is labled a gang, but they are also christians, just like neo-nazi and the KKK are christians, priests who molest little boys are still christians...at the very least most of them beilieve they are... but does that mean all christians are racisist and sexualy perverse, no.
So if some juggalo's commit crimes why is everyone else held accountable for thier actions?
Also people who share like minds and live near eachother get together and hang out, some go to bars, some get together and play videogames or rpg/board games and some do other things outdoors like hunt or birdwatch etc.. my point is there are a lot of "gangs" of teens and adults in the world , the definition of "gang" really just means a group of people.. so a group of friends who hang out a lot are a gang... a lot of groups of people hang out and get in trouble, the difference is they don't have a label hanging over thier head for people to notice and use against them.
Now i've heard that some juggalo's who live near eachother form actual gangs in thier neighboorhoods and use the word juggalo or whatever as a name for thier street gang... i was born and raised in chicago and i like to read about things and watch documentories about random stuff so i know a little bit about the history of gangs in chicago from the 1950-1970's.
And i know that bloods and/or crips like most gangs didn't start out as what they are now, most gangs start either from good intentions or by a group hoodlums or just emotionally/mentally damaged people who decided they should start a gang and run thier hood for whatever reason.. im guessing power and/or money.
It's common and understandable, it happens, but because they are juggalo's living that lifestyle doesn't mean all juggalo's are liek that or the general juggalo community supports that.
Like i said, christianity has broken off into many sub groups and they are able to stay seperate with different beliefs and lifestyles and people don't really hold the actions of one group agaisnt the others. why do juggalos need to be labled like this.. it's no right.
And it looks to me that out of all these gangs the fbi list the onlyone that isn't organized or have leaderships are juggalos.
From what i know about "gangs" they usually have leaders at the top that make gang rules and/or marching orders... then the local chapters,sets,sections or whater have someone running that specefic area. I know they say juggalo's are a "hybrid gang" but what if a group of lil wayne fans or metalica fans get together and start a gang in thier neighborhood?
Speaking of metalica, a lot of people have commited suicide and it has been attributed to "fade to black".. and what about cullumbine.. i think they liked nin and manson but im guessing they like metalica too.. point is though it's not the bands fault for what people do.
People do messed up stuff because they are human beings not because they are fans of a specific music group or movie or video game, or because they do or don't beilieve in a god.

oz Monday, August 13, 2012
the most boring part of this post is the commonly held assertion amongst some Americans that Guns'n'Roses 'wrote some of the greatest music of all time...'.
meh, more like the musical equivalent of the KFC family chicken bucket.

The Colonel Tuesday, August 14, 2012
Delicious.

musicservices4less Tuesday, August 14, 2012
I think it is important if you are interested in this topic, that you read the relevant portion of the report. So here it is. Full report at http://www.fbi.gov/stats-services/publications/2011-national-gang-threat-assessment/2011-national-gang-threat-assessment#Expansion
The expansion of hybrid gangs—non-traditional gangs
with multiple affiliations—is a continued phenomenon in
many jurisdictions nationwide. Because of their multiple
affiliations, ethnicities, migratory nature, and nebulous
structure, hybrid gangs are difficult to track, identify, and
target as they are transient and continuously evolving.
Furthermore, these multi-ethnic, mixed-gender gangs
pose a unique challenge to law enforcement because
they are adopting national symbols and gang members
often crossover from gang to gang. Hybrid gangs are of
particular concern to law enforcement because members
often escalate their criminal activity in order to gain
attention and respect.
Hybrid gangs, which are present in at least 25 states,
are fluid in size and structure, yet tend to adopt similar
characteristics of larger urban gangs, including their
own identifiers, rules, and recruiting methods. Like
most street gangs, hybrid gang members commit a
multitude of street and violent crime. Law enforcement
reporting suggests that hybrid gangs have evolved
from neighborhood crews that formed to expand drug
trafficking, or from an absence of loyalty to nationally
recognized gangs in their region.
*Law enforcement officials in many jurisdictions
nationwide report an increase in juvenile gang
membership and violent crime among hybrid and
local gangs, according to 2010 NGIC reporting.
*NGIC reporting indicates that hybrid gangs are
dominating nationally recognized gangs in some
jurisdictions and merging with other gangs to
expand their membership.
Hybrid and Almighty Latin King
Nation (ALKN) Gang Members Arrested
on Drug Charges
In November 2010, hybrid gang members in
Pontiac, Michigan, known the “New World Order,”
were charged along with members of the ALKN
for numerous drug offenses. Several guns, drugs,
dozens of cell phones and $10,000 in cash were
seized by FBI, DEA and local police departments.
Many of the gang members arrested were juveniles
and young adults.
The Juggalos, a loosely-organized hybrid gang, are
rapidly expanding into many US communities. Although
recognized as a gang in only four states, many Juggalos
subsets exhibit gang-like behavior and engage in
criminal activity and violence. Law enforcement officials
in at least 21 states have identified criminal Juggalo
sub-sets, according to NGIC reporting.
*NGIC reporting indicates that Juggalo gangs areexpanding in New Mexico primarily because theyare attracted to the tribal and cultural traditionsof the Native Americans residing nearby.
Most crimes committed by Juggalos are sporadic, disorganized, individualistic, and often involve simpleassault, personal drug use and possession, pettytheft, and vandalism. However, open source reporting suggests that a small number of Juggalos are forming more organized subsets and engaging in more gang-like
criminal activity, such as felony assaults, thefts, robberies,
and drug sales. Social networking websites are a
popular conveyance for Juggalo sub-culture to communicate
and expand.
*In January 2011, a suspected Juggalo member
shot and wounded a couple in King County,
Washington, according to open source reporting.
*Juggalos are traditionally fans of the musical group the Insane Clown Posse. Arizona, California, Pennsylvania, and Utah are the only US states that recognize Juggalos as a gang.
Juggalos’ disorganization and lack of structure within
their groups, coupled with their transient nature, makes
it difficult to classify them and identify their members
and migration patterns. Many criminal Juggalo subsets
are comprised of transient or homeless individuals,
according to law enforcement reporting. Most Juggalo
criminal groups are not motivated to migrate based
upon traditional needs of a gang. However, law enforcement
reporting suggests that Juggalo criminal activity
has increased over the past several years and has
expanded to several other states. Transient, criminal
Juggalo groups pose a threat to communities due to the
potential for violence, drug use/sales, and their general
destructive and violent nature.
* In January 2010, two suspected Juggalo associates
were charged with beating and robbing an
elderly homeless man.
Juggalos
Although law enforcement officials in Arizona,
California, Pennsylvania, Utah, and Washington
report the most Juggalo gang-related criminal
activity, Juggalos are present in Colorado, Delaware,
Florida, Illinois, Iowa, Kansas, Massachusetts,
Michigan, New Mexico, New Hampshire,
North Carolina, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania,
Tennessee, Texas, and Virginia, according to
NGIC reporting.

@redmondlondon Wednesday, August 15, 2012
Digital Music News nails it again.

@cskoyles Wednesday, August 15, 2012
An interesting read.

Follow Us