Follow Us

·

RIAA Quietly Drops a Suit; "Making Available" Questions Linger

Wednesday, June 11, 2008
by  presnikoff

The RIAA has quietly dropped a two-year file-swapping lawsuit, a development that intensifies questions related to its methods for identifying and prosecuting individual file-sharers.  The case, Warner v. Cassin, was voluntarily dropped without explanation, though attorney Ray Beckerman pointed to a potential challenge of its "making available" infringement methodology.

The RIAA has traditionally argued that merely making content available online constitutes infringement.  The group frequently identifies and plucks files from an open file-sharing folder to prove its point, an induced upload that has received some scrutiny in the courts.  That includes the case against Joan Cassin, according to Beckerman.  "Substantial briefing had taken place in the case over the 'making available' issue, and further rulings were brought to the court's attention on the subject," Beckerman explained.  That includes Atlantic v. Howell and Capitol v. Thomas, as well as a collection of other cases. 



OUR SPONSORS