Nearly Half of All Charting Songs Are One-Hit Wonders

Think getting a hit song is hard?

Then try getting another hit song. According to some exhaustive research just concluded by University of Colorado Denver assistant professor Storm Gloor, nearly one-half of all charting artists never appear again ― ever.  And this isn’t a recent phenomenon – it’s a fairly consistent metric dating back to the mid-1950s.

Gloor combed through Billboard charts dating back to 1955, and moved through 2005 for the analysis.  He reached out to a number of chart statisticians, including Billboard’s Geoff Mayfield and Joel Whitburn, to compile this table of fleeting chart insanity. And he found a scarily-consistent level of failure over the 50-year span.

That is, out of 5,745 artists charting for the first time, 2,732 never reappeared.  That’s a 47.5 percent disappearance rate.  “It is interesting to note that the percentage of artists falling into this category is fairly consistent over the fifty-year time period analyzed,” Gloor shared.

Actually, that’s just one aspect of a broader chart analysis enabled by a research grant from the Music Entertainment Industry Educators Association (MEIEA).  The complete report is here.

9 Responses

  1. billeeto

    is LMFAO considered a one-hit wonder, or is it one and one-half hits?

  2. RP

    This happens because most people don’t know what they’re doing in the first place. How about over 80% of all hits are accidental?

  3. @AndyHermannLA

    This happens because most people don’t know what they’re doing in the first place. How about over 80% of all hits are accidental?

  4. @amyofftherecord

    Interesting, depressing, and a testament to the finicky nature of music fans

  5. OldenGreen

    A person who has a hit with one band; then quits and has a hit with another band; then forms another band and has a hit — is this person with multiple hits a one hit wonder or, are perhaps the three bands each considered one hit wonders?

  6. JohnMCA72

    I have the utmost respect for anybody who can manage even ONE SINGLE chart hit! This study just reinforces why.