Google and YouTube Under Fire After Ads Appear in Extremist Videos

Google and YouTube Under Fire After Ads Appear in Extremist Videos

Open Grid Scheduler (CC by 2.0)

So, why did top advertising companies appear in ads for extremist, racist, and other hateful videos?

Google and YouTube are facing heat after the UK government accused the company of profiting from hateful videos.

The Times first reported that top advertising brands had appeared in extremist videos.  Google runs a blacklist to prevent ads from appearing on hateful, racist, or extremist videos, but The Times found that the ads run anyway.

The examples are everywhere.  Reporter Alexi Mostrous, Head of Investigations, first found a L’Oreal ad in Steven Anderson’s hate-filled preaching video.  Dame Helen Mirren appeared in the company’s campaign to promote the Prince’s Trust.  The charity helps empower young people to get jobs.  The UK government banned the preacher from Britain after posting a hate-filled response to a terrorist attack in Orlando.  He said,

“The good news is that there’s 50 less pedophiles in the world.”

Image by The Times

Various government agencies, including Transport for London, found themselves promoted in other extremist videos.

UK newspaper The Guardian, Sainsbury’s, Nissan, and the Diana Award charity also appeared in similar videos.  The BBC, the Royal Navy, and Visit Scotland ads occasionally appeared in former KKK grand-wizard David Duke’s videos.  They also appear on videos for Holocaust denier Michael Savage, another banned DJ, and an Osama Bin Laden sympathizer.

Separately, a Royal Air Force advert appeared on an anti-semitic and pro-Hitler video posted by King David the Recruiter, a Christian rap artist.  King David’s music is also sold through Google’s Play Store.

The Times noted that YouTube inadvertently paid out extremist posters for the advertisements shown.  YouTube posters usually receive $7.60 for every 1,000 ad views.  Google of course also takes a cut.

Alexi Mostrous found that the most popular extremist videos have more than a million hits.

The Times posted an image of how Google’s DoubleClick Ad Exchange works.

Image by The Times

Sir Martin Sorrell, head of WPP, an advertising and PR company, said,

“The fundamental issue is that you [Google] have to take responsibility for this as a media company.  You are not a passive digital engineer tightening the digital pipes with your digital spanner and not responsible for the flow-through of content of those pipes, you are responsible for it.”

In response to the article, major brands, along with the UK government and The Guardian, have pulled their ads from YouTube.  A French advertising group that manages O2, EDF, and Royal Mail announced their pullout as well.

The UK government criticized Google over the report. A government statement reads,

“Google is responsible for ensuring the high standards applied to government advertising are adhered to and that adverts do not appear alongside inappropriate content. We have placed a temporary restriction on our YouTube advertising pending reassurances from Google that government messages can be delivered in a safe and appropriate way.”

The government also summoned Google for an explanation.  The search giant and YouTube promised to make “significant changes” to company policies to address the problem.  A spokesman for the search giant said,

We accept that we don’t always get it right, and that sometimes, ads appear where they should not. We’re committed to doing better, and will make changes to our policies and brand controls for advertisers.”

3 Responses

  1. Anonymous

    We can all agree that anti-Semites, nazis and homophobes never should be supported.

    But we also need to remember that it’s very, very hard to distinguish between extremists and people you just disagree with.

    And values change all the time. The American president’s saying defamatory stuff that would get anybody else blacklisted, so I honestly can’t see how you can deal with this in a fair way.

  2. PiratesWinLOL

    “They also appear on videos for Holocaust denier Michael Savage”

    michael savage is jewish and daniel sanchez is an idiot. now stop spreading libel and fake news please.

    the fascists who continue to be butthurt about people using their right to free speech, to express opinions they don’t agree with, can go to hell. your digusting attempts to censor people on social media are revolting. i see no difference between you and nazis burning books.

  3. Larry

    It would appear the left wing governments aren’t fans of conservatives and right wingers, which are dominating youtube through facts. So they also get labelled as extremists.
    Whether you agree with that or not the issue is that another form of freedom of speech is being removed, or made harder to discover.