Mechanical Licensing Collective Hands a Juicy Contract to HFA — Critics Call the Deal Crooked

The newly-minted — and funded — Mechanical Licensing Collective has just awarded a plum contract to the Harry Fox Agency, owned by private equity firm the Blackstone Group.  Critics are quickly pointing to a ‘no-bid contract’ based on political horse-trading, with HFA assailed for serious licensing problems in the past.

The HFA award was formally announced this week, with the Mechanical Licensing Collective (MLC) now granting lucrative contracts and coveted positions following its monstrous initial budget grant.  Also receiving a choice bid was ConsenSys, an Ethereum blockchain-focused tech play.

“Technology company ConsenSys and mechanical licensing administrator Harry Fox Agency (HFA) received unanimous approval from the MLC Board to become the primary vendors responsible for managing the matching of digital uses to musical works, distributing mechanical royalties, and onboarding songwriters, composers, lyricists, and music publishers and their catalogs to the database,” the MLC emailed DMN.

The awards follow an extremely lucrative funding award of $62 million, which only carries the MLC for one year past its launch date of January 1st, 2021.  Major publishers like Universal Music Publishing Group, Sony/ATV, Warner/Chappell, and Downtown Music Publishing are undoubtedly giving kudos to NMPA topper David Israelite for that healthy tranche, with one streaming negotiator suffering from ‘mere exhaustion’ against the ‘unmedicated’ but ferocious Washington-based negotiator.

Amazingly, another major streaming service complained that the MLC’s initial $66.25 million budget was ‘at least three times‘ the cost of running a mechanical licensing agency, according to their estimates. But streaming services seem willing to pay a premium for an end to the endless copyright liabilities.

Now, it’s time to start spending.  Though not before a few favors are repaid.

MLC Board chair Alisa Coleman pointed to an exhaustive selection process, though numerous sources pointed DMN to a backroom, ‘no bid contract’ deal based on earlier accords with the powerful Blackstone Group. “After completing a rigorous evaluation process, HFA in collaboration with ConsenSys is the clear choice to ensure that the MLC has a solid platform to deliver on its mission,” Coleman relayed.

“These vendors will successfully help the MLC deliver not only what is required under the MMA, but also improve the overall mechanical licensing process in the United States.”

Sounds fair, though competing vendors probably didn’t stand a chance. Last month, a top executive at one of the largest streaming services tipped Digital Music News to the HFA award. The source, who was involved in extensive negotiations over the initial funding amounts (paid by the streaming services), promised DMN that “HFA will get their contract” based on earlier horse-trading involving Blackstone, a powerful lobbyist that nearly scuttled the entire Music Modernization Act (MMA) over concerns tied to HFA and its sister company, SESAC.

As the MMA steamrolled towards approvals in both Congressional chambers, sources noted that Blackstone quickly feared the extinction of its two music properties.  HFA, a company blamed — fairly or unfairly — for creating an enormous mess related to unpaid streaming mechanicals, looked easily replaced by the MLC, while SESAC, a smaller performance rights organization, was supremely threatened by an MLC that was likely to spread beyond mechanical licensing.

The result, according to sources with knowledge of the backroom dealings, is that the NMPA agreed to narrow the scope of the MLC’s responsibilities while promising a juicy HFA contract ahead. Which is exactly what happened this week.

Among the sharp critics of the award is vocal artist advocate David Lowery, who abruptly quit the Mechanical Licensing Collective for unknown reasons.

Lowery has been a huge thorn in the sides of several heavyweight streaming services, not to mention major publishers. He spearheaded the first lawsuits against streaming services for non-payment of mechanical licenses, while outing HFA for massive underpayments, mismatches, and flat-out fraud. Lowery helped to provoke the crisis that ultimately led to the passage of the MMA and its resolutions around mechanical licensing moving forward.

Lowery declined to offer a reason for his MLC exit.  Though maybe this had something to do with it.

“The problem is that HFA was the third-party licensing contractor hired by Spotify and other streaming services to obtain licenses from songwriters and publishers,” Lowery wrote on his site, The Trichordist, earlier today.  “HFA did not properly do their job leaving streaming services exposed to massive copyright infringement lawsuits (from people like me).  They created the problem that led to the creation of the Music Licensing Collective so now they are rewarded with the contract to run the matching of musical works and paying artists?!?!”

“Didn’t they just fail spectacularly when asked by Spotify to do this job?  Didn’t the Spotify class action and the four other private lawsuits prove HFA incapable of doing the job?”

Lowery was once the frontman for successful 90s group Cracker.  So he experienced the mechanical meltdown firsthand — and he solidly blames HFA for the mess.  “HFA was the company that was supposed to pay these streaming royalties back out to the songwriters.  They didn’t do that either.  Where is that money? Shouldn’t the Copyright Office look into this?

“This company was one of the main reasons songwriters didn’t get their mechanicals for 7 going on 8 years.   What the fuck were you guys thinking?”

Also slamming the decision is Jeff Price of Audiam, owned by Canadian rights organization SOCAN.

In comments to the U.S. Copyright Office submitted ahead of the selection of HFA, Price pointed to an uncanny competitive advantage enjoyed by HFA.  All of which is seriously bad news for mechanical competitors like Audiam.

“As a vendor to the MLC, HFA would now have unique and unfettered access to all music streaming data including, but not limited to, a list of every musical recording distributed with all the associated metadata, a list of every registered music publisher, songwriter, the data points connecting recordings to the composition, stream counts and revenue earned by every musical works owner, creator and administrator around the world, giving them a unique un-replicable competitive advantage in the private market against other privately held companies.

“In effect, based on their own admission as to the value of the data, and their articulation of how they intend to compete in this market space, their designation as a vendor to the MLC will allow HFA to know whom to solicit, how much each entity earns and streams, what compositions each entity represents, how to contact each entity, what each entities annual value is, and more.

Sounds good for Blackstone, whose once-struggling HFA is now surging back from the brink — and suddenly enjoying a coveted catbird seat in the mechanical licensing space.

Looking ahead, at least two sources have promised an upcoming award to SoundExchange and its SXWorks division.

“They’ll get their piece [of the MLC budget],” one exec at a streaming service promised. That’s perfect news for SoundExchange CEO Michael Huppe, who — despite an extraordinary ‘non-profit’ salary north of $1.4 million — is now weathering serious long-term challenges for SoundExchange and its non-interactive recorded music licensing focus. Most notably, Huppe’s SoundExchange lost a critical client, Pandora, which pulled a large portion of its licensing duties away from the agency for reasons reportedly tied to large administrative overhead and processing problems.

More as this develops.  Written while listening to FKA twigs and Slaine.



12 Responses

    • Anonymous

      The copyright office or someone should look into this because this stinks to high heaven. Hire the company that created the mess?!?! Really?!?! Looks like the composers get screwed again….

  1. Grinch

    SX lost a critical client? No, more like direct licensing around paying the artist’s share, The companies doing this should be ashamed, but you won’t shame them, Paul, because you you’re fixated on Huppe’s competitive salary instead of issues that matter, like routing around the artists’ 45% share. Shame on you.

    • Paul Resnikoff

      That’s not the situation from Pandora’s perspective. According to the investors and execs I spoke with, SoundExchange was rife with mismatches and huge administrative cuts. SoundExchange didn’t even properly notify artists of Pandora’s pullout. Just one of several competency issues raised here.

  2. Rabbi Shlomo

    What did you expect? Honesty? Transparency? A new regime? I expected incompetence.

  3. Anon

    The only real positive take away from this is that Richard Thompson is on the MLC Board now, and ConsenSys has a seat at the table. Having the organization (HFA) that was a major player, and reason behind the mismanagement of so many mechanical licenses in the past get this contract is a bit suspicious. They have lacked the infrastructure and technology for decades. I really hope for the sake of song writers, that the partnership with Consensys will bring HFA into the 21st century. Get the popcorn ready!

    • Anonymous

      It won’t. Blockchain isn’t going to make HFA any better. This isn’t about hiring the best vendor for the job. This is about satisfying an arrangement Blackstone must’ve made to ensure that HFA would become the vendor, in order to allow for a) the MMA to become law, and b) the black box to remain as large as possible due to HFA’s incompetence, so that the NMPA has more of that black box money to steal for themselves, rather than pay it to its rightful owners.

      This is a heist, and the MMA made it legal.

      • Anon

        I guess I’m just trying to be optimistic. Your points made are valid, and without Blackstone lobbyist, and their fiduciary responsibility to SESAC/HFA there was probably a snowball’s chance in hell that HFA would get the contract. My last remaining (optimistic) opinion is that the MMA will usher in public database, for other smarter, technology driven companies to come up with solutions and create a system that works in the favor of the ALL rights holders, not just the ones NMPA represents. Does anyone know how long (the Term) of the vendor contract?

  4. mr.wayne askew

    hello;to audiam inc. e-mail ; this is for my lifetime total earned in the amount of 8,000.00 dollars in mechanical royalties to reach me doing my christmas gift giving season. so i can give out shares and christrmas gifts to my business media production and song writing partners who has the same partnership afairs in the music business; please contact me at my mailing address in concern with this matter at;mr.wayne askew crossroads episcopal church mail room at; 420 courtland street ne atlanta georgia 30308-3405.or deposit some money in my bank account for this christmas holiday season. and to my checking routing number is;263190812 my account number is;5424 3246 0090 3281 my audiam inc code number is;hotlanta c a 2@ – casesincitive h -i look forward to receive a reply from you real soon.think you very much.

    • Anonymous

      Umm, either I don’t get the inside joke, or this person doesn’t understand how the internet works.

  5. Data Analyst

    The music industry deserves a better company to drive the future of our industry even if it takes more time. HFA has major data integrity issues and I would assume systematic issues too. Things will only get worse now that HFA has the MLC.