AccuRadio Says SoundExchange Lawsuit Was A “Complete Surprise To Us”

Yesterday, Digital Music News first reported on a new lawsuit brought forth by SoundExchange against AccuRadio for unpaid royalties. Now AccuRadio has reached out to say the lawsuit is a total surprise for them.

SoundExchange filed the lawsuit in an Illinois federal court, alleging that AccuRadio’s royalty payments “slowed and finally stopped in 2018.” The complaint says the two parties hammer out a deal for the missing payments in 2020, but that AccuRadio “failed to make required payments” as designated under this plan. SoundExchange says it then audited royalties paid through 2015 and 2017 and identified “additional royalties due” from AccuRadio.

A structured forbearance agreement from June 2023 would see AccuRadio making an initial down payment, monthly installments, and then a “single balloon payment” in 2017 to conclude the owed royalties. SoundExchange is seeking the alleged missed statutory and forbearance-agreement royalties, as well as a full accounting of royalties from June 2021 onward for SoundExchange to audit.

Now AccuRadio has reached out to Digital Music News with a statement about the lawsuit. “SoundExchange’s lawsuit against AccuRadio comes as a complete surprise to us, as we have been working with SoundExchange negotiating a fair and reasonable payment plan for several months now, working in what we believed was in good faith from both parties,” says AccuRadio Founder & CEO Kurt Hanson.

“In fact, we thought our latest proposal was being vetted by SoundExchange and would be adopted by the parties with few modifications. Rather than ‘refusing to pay royalties,’ as the SoundExchange press release states, in fact AccuRadio has been a consistently reliable SoundExchange licensee for the vast majority of the past 20+ years.”

“SoundExchange’s implication that AccuRadio hasn’t paid royalties since 2018 is erroneous and fails to note that AccuRadio resumed full payments in early 2021 and continued until very recently,” Hanson concludes. He says the core problem for AccuRadio and other web broadcasters like it is that the royalty rates for music played via online radio are wildly higher than other forms of radio, or other forms of royalties such as songwriters’ royalties.”

“AM/FM stations pay no sound recording royalties for terrestrial broadcasts, and satellite radio is rumored to pay a royalty of about 15% of revenue,” Hanson continues. “Yet AccuRadio’s SoundExchange royalty obligation in some months has worked out to be as high as 45% to 78% of its revenues.”

Hanson notes that the high music streaming royalty rates are challenging for small and independent webcasters like AccuRadio, who don’t have deep pockets. “At AccuRadio, we love the medium of online radio—with its ease-of-use, incredible variety, personalization features, and reasonable spot load—and we intend to continue to work with SoundExchange. Either directly or via a judge, to enter into a fair and reasonable payment plan for past obligations and to resume current-period payments ASAP.”