
Photo Credit: Eddy Grant by Stuart Sevastos / CC by 2.0
Eddy Grant finally scores a victory against Donald Trump four years after filing a copyright infringement suit against him.
District Court Judge John G. Koeltl has ruled that Donald Trump is on the hook legally and financially for his use of Eddy Grant’s 1982 hit, “Electric Avenue,” without the musician’s permission during a video promoting Trump’s 2020 re-election campaign. The judge rejected Trump’s legal arguments as either moot or without merit, finding him liable for monetary damages.
The ruling leaves one question up in the air — whether a jury will be convened to decide on the amount owed. Eddy Grant asked in his filing back in 2020 for lawyers’ fees and $300,000 in damages.
Regardless, the ruling is just the latest in a seemingly never-ending stream of litigation against Donald Trump for music he has used in his political campaigns. Artists who have filed suit against him include the Rolling Stones, Celine Dion, and Jack White.
Because Eddy Grant’s case involved an animated video mocking Trump’s opponent at the time, Joe Biden, with “Electric Avenue” playing in the background, Trump’s lawyers tried to claim it constituted fair use. They asserted that the cartoon was political commentary, not a campaign commercial soliciting donations, and that the song was “contextually transformed” by its use in the clip, further insisting that Grant didn’t even have the track copyrighted.
But Judge Koeltl disagreed with all these points, referring back to an earlier ruling in which he described the video as a “wholesale copying of music to accompany a political campaign ad.”
Grant’s lawsuit first came back in 2020 when then-president Trump and his campaign aides posted the video using “Electric Avenue” on Twitter, gaining millions of views and around 100,000 retweets before it was taken down. Known for his socially conscious music, Grant stated at the time that the use of his song to amplify “derogatory political rhetoric” was “wicked” and a source of “considerable emotional distress.”