After Rampant Charges of Corruption, CISAC Suspends Spanish Collecting Society SGAE’s Membership

Following Refusal to Implement Much-Needed Changes, CISAC Suspends Corrupt Spanish Collecting Society GSAC's Membership
  • Save

Top music industry executives and music organizations don’t think too fondly of fraudulent Spanish collecting society, SGAE.

That’s putting it lightly.

First, between 2003 and 2007, top SGAE executives illegally misappropriated millions of euros.  Authorities in Madrid also arrested Enrique Loras, SGAE’s Director General, and Ricardo Azcoaga, the society’s Financial Director.

Then, in 2011, civil guard officers raided the once-powerful collecting society’s headquarters in downtown Madrid.  Four SGAE executives – including veteran Chairman of the Board, Eduardo ‘Teddy’ Bautista – had engaged in a large-scale corruption scheme.  Police charged him, along with five others, with embezzlement, fraud, and gross administration.

Years later, the embattled Spanish collecting society claimed it had changed it ways.  Those two high-profile instances now seemed like a distant memory.

But, just like a leopard can’t change its spots, SGAE can’t seem to change its ways.

Two years ago, Spanish authorities discovered the collecting society, including its beleaguered Chairman, had once again engaged in large-scale fraud.

SGAE members and executives had colluded with top television executives in the country.  In a scheme known as ‘La Reuda’ (The Wheel), TV executives would play songs late at night, listing SGAE-designated names as publisher, writer, and composer.  Then, when it came time to collect, TV executives and SGAE members split the royalties between themselves.  Police subsequently raided the collecting society’s headquarters once again, arresting eighteen executives.

The corruption had grown so much under Bautista, the International Confederation of Music Publishers called on CISAC, the International Confederation of Societies of Authors and Composers, a global coalition of collecting societies, to suspend SGAE’s membership.

For years, Teddy Bautista, the collecting society’s ringleader, had also refused to step down, until he was finally voted out.  He continues to fight all the charges to this day.

Last year, and hoping to leave behind its troubled past once more, SGAE held board elections.

With a record low turnout, members voted for new leadership.  Only 1,373 members of the society’s 18,970 members – 7.25% – participated.  The thirty-five new members include guitarist Josemi Carmona, Heivo, and rock singer Huecco.

Unfortunately for the collecting society, the majority of its new board members have readily defended ‘The Wheel’ scam.

Now, SGAE has lost its coveted membership with CISAC.

When CISAC just can’t handle any more corruption.

Earlier this morning, the General Assembly of CISAC, voted for the temporary expulsion of SGAE.

The global coalition had closely worked with the Spanish collecting society for months.  CISAC had long investigated complaints of discriminatory treatment of rightsholders, unfair practices, and unfair distribution of royalties.

In April 2018, the global coalition presented SGAE with a comprehensive report, detailing recommendations for changes to the society’s governance rules, statutes, and royalty distribution practices.  Yet, in December 2018, after SGAE refused to implement the requirements, the CISAC Board of Directors announced the opening of a sanction procedure.

Today’s vote for a one-year expulsion follows an in-depth analysis of recent reforms set in motion by SGAE’s new President, Pilar Jurado.  The Spanish collecting society had proposed several much-needed changes, yet SGAE’s General Assembly hasn’t approved of them.

So, until the embattled Spanish collecting society implements these changes, expect SGAE to remain out of CISAC.


Featured image by CISAC.

2 Responses

  1. Dean Hajas

    Exactky his is CISAC’s treatment of Spain ?? any different then the USA – President Donald Trump calling Canada ?? an intellectual” property thief haven “. In fact CAPAC was dissolved because of Profiteering and the current model of SOCAN and CIPO creates orphaned Royalties in the Billions. The propensity for PRO’s to double dip and not proclaim Levies and Tariffs income, Radio splits revenues , foreign imalgemated CISAC contribution to USA – Canada – is uncertain and ends us up with a Black box account of over a $billion dollars worth of orphaned Royalties. With 38 PRO’s in Canada alone, all fighting to get their Administrative hands on our Royalties… the propensity is trickery and thievery with hard evidence in hand, with incident investigative reports generated at the RCMP fraud department. Make no mistake.. the Governance of our music industry created with the CRB is enabling corporations Bell Rigers Cogeco to be legalized profiteers by devaluing our sale rate by getting rid of Broadcast and Transmission our of the legal definition of Streaming. Challenge any one of the PRO’s Snd their executive board and find out their collective response. I say.. investigate all of them across the board.. and stop the witch hunt and making example of one only.

  2. Anonymous

    Hey that sounds like what they got in states lol